251.943.9200
<< View All Posts

Signs Your Thermostat May Be Broken

Read time: 5 min.
A man changing the temperature on his home's programmable thermostat.

Before you start panicking about a huge repair bill for your AC or furnace, you should check the small control box on the wall. Spotting broken thermostat signs early can save you a lot of stress and money.

Many homeowners overlook this vital component, but it’s the brain of your entire HVAC system. A faulty thermostat can be the hidden cause of your comfort issues. In this article, we’ll guide you through the most common signs of a failing thermostat, helping you determine if this small device is the actual cause of your issues.

Your HVAC System Refuses To Turn On

You walk over to the thermostat and switch your system to “cool” or “heat.” Then you wait, and nothing happens. Your first thought might be that your entire air conditioner or furnace has died, prompting the need for urgent AC or heating repair.

But the problem might not be that serious. Since the thermostat sends the signal to start the system, a malfunction can prevent the HVAC unit from turning on at all. If the system powers on but doesn’t produce hot or cold air, you’re likely dealing with a different issue. However, if the system is completely unresponsive, the thermostat may be to blame.

A silent HVAC system is often one of the first and clearest signs of thermostat failure. Fortunately, replacing a thermostat is far less expensive than replacing an entire air conditioning or heating unit. In some cases, a professional may also need to repair or inspect the electrical wiring to resolve the issue.

The AC or Heater Just Keeps Running

On the other hand, you might have a heating and cooling system that never shuts off. The air conditioner runs constantly until your house feels like an icebox. Or the heat keeps blasting long after the room is warm, pushing out endless hot air.

Your thermostat’s job is to read the room’s temperature and instruct the system to shut down once it reaches the target temperature you set. If it can’t read the temperature correctly, it will never send that vital “stop” signal. This constant operation puts excessive strain on HVAC components and can lead to premature failure.

This isn’t just annoying. It also wastes a significant amount of energy and increases your energy bills. In fact, a thermostat that’s not working correctly can cost you a lot of money over time, and it’s a clear sign that you need to either repair or replace the thermostat controls.

Telltale Broken Thermostat Signs To Watch For

Thermostat problems can show up in a few different ways. Some are loud and clear, while others are a bit more subtle. Here are a few more specific things to keep an eye on to determine if you have a broken thermostat.

Extreme Temperature Swings

Your home should feel consistently comfortable. However, with a faulty thermostat, you may notice erratic temperature fluctuations. The heat kicks on and makes the house feel like a sauna before it shuts off, letting the space get frigidly cold before it turns on again.

These big swings happen because the thermostat has lost its ability to accurately sense the indoor temperature. It’s misjudging the room, which leads to poor comfort control and can negatively impact your home’s air quality. A properly working thermostat should maintain a steady temperature that you barely notice.

Short-Cycling Your HVAC System

Does your furnace or air conditioner turn on for a minute, shut off, and then turn back on again just a few moments later? This is called short cycling. It’s inefficient and puts a lot of strain on your HVAC equipment, often requiring a heat pump repair or other service call.

Before you blame the thermostat, you should check your air filter. A dirty or clogged air filter can restrict airflow and cause short cycling. But if your filter is clean, the issue often points back to faulty thermostat wiring or a malfunctioning sensor.

It Forgets Your Programmed Settings

Many of us use programmable thermostats to automate our heating and cooling schedules. If your thermostat repeatedly forgets programmed settings, it’s a major inconvenience. A smart device should make life easier, not more frustrating.

When a thermostat forgets programmed information, the thermostat itself is likely failing. Its internal components are wearing out, or the battery backup is dead. This is a clear sign that it’s time for a thermostat replacement, as it no longer reliably manages your settings.

The Display Is Unresponsive or Blank

This one is pretty straightforward. If your digital thermostat display is blank or the temperature gauge won’t respond when you press the buttons, something is wrong. Before you assume it’s broken, you should try replacing the batteries.

If fresh batteries don’t fix it, then you’re likely dealing with dead electrical components. The thermostat isn’t receiving power or may have simply reached the end of its useful life. This is one of the clearest indications that an upgrade is needed.

Why Did My Thermostat Break?

Thermostats fail for a few common reasons. Most of the time, the cause is fairly simple. Knowing why can help you with future heating maintenance and prevent other problems.

Old Age and Wear

Like any electronic gadget, thermostats don’t last forever. The average thermostat lasts about 10 years. Over time, wires can become loose, sensors lose accuracy, and internal parts just wear out from use.

Older mechanical thermostats contain moving parts that can degrade. Newer digital and smart thermostats are reliable, but their electronic circuits can also fail over time. Regular maintenance can sometimes catch a failing unit before it leaves you in the cold or heat.

Improper Location

Where your thermostat is installed matters a lot. If it’s placed in a location that gets direct sunlight, it will think your home is much warmer than it really is. This will cause your air conditioner to run much more than necessary.

Similarly, putting it near a heat source such as a lamp, television, or kitchen appliance will also give it false readings. The U.S. Department of Energy suggests installing thermostats on an interior wall away from direct heat or drafts. This allows it to get an accurate reading of the room’s average temperature.

Time for an Upgrade to a Smart Thermostat

If you confirm your old thermostat is broken, this is a great chance to upgrade. A new programmable thermostat or smart thermostat can offer huge benefits. They give you far more control over your home’s climate and help you save money.

Smart thermostats learn your habits and can adjust the temperature automatically to save energy when you’re away. You can also control them from your phone, letting you turn on the AC on your way home from work. When considering a new AC or heating installation, including a smart thermostat is a wise decision. These devices can bring a lot of modern conveniences and significantly lower your monthly energy costs. 

Final Thoughts

Figuring out what’s wrong with your HVAC system can feel overwhelming. However, the problem often lies with the thermostat, which is a relatively simple fix. If your system won’t turn on, runs continuously, or cycles erratically, the thermostat is the first place to check. Ignoring these broken thermostat signs can lead to bigger bills and an uncomfortable home. If you’re still unsure about the issue, seeking help from a professional air conditioning repair service is a good idea.

Table Of Contents

  • Address

1905 S McKenzie St, Foley, AL 36535

  • Hours

Mon - Sun 6am- 10pm
24/7 Emergency Service

  • Call Us
Call us for a free estimate
251-943-9200
© 2025 
AirMax LLC